Pedestrian Pound Update: England Annex

Key document information

This is a web page version of a report from Living Streets, which is also published as a pdf document. This version has been adapted to focus on providing accessibility for people who want to enlarge the text or to use a screen reader.

The key information below is taken from the document cover pages:

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed in this report are those of the authors alone, and do not necessarily represent the views of the client or the funders. In addition, whilst Transport for Quality of Life has used due skill, care and diligence to ensure the information in this document is accurate, we do not guarantee the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of that information; and cannot accept liability for any loss or damages of any kind resulting from reliance on the information or guidance this document contains. Any errors or omissions are not the responsibility of the funders.

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to thank the following for help with the English case studies or input during the stakeholder workshop (in alphabetical order by organisation and surname):

Arun District Council (Denise Vine); Bike 4 Health; Canny Insights; Eldon Square; Gateshead Council; Kada Research (Karl Dalgleish); Leicester City Council (Satbir Kaur, Steve Richards); Living Streets; Momentum Consultancy (David Hart, Kana Nomoto); Newcastle City Council; North East England Chamber of Commerce; North Tyneside Council; The Portman Estate (Simon Loomes); Sheffield City Council (Lucia Lorente-Arnau, Roger Nowell); Shrewsbury BID (Seb Slater); Shopshire Council (Claire Evans); South Tyneside Council; St Paul's Church (Whitley Bay); Street Systems; Sunderland City Council; Transport North East; Volterra (Peter Reddy); Westminster City Council (Anju Banga).

Produced by

Transport for Quality of Life Limited

Introduction

This Annex sets out the context for public realm and walking improvements in high streets in England, including the geography and social context, as well as key targets, policies, funding and delivery mechanisms for such schemes. The evidence for greater investment in walkable high streets can be found in the main report which includes examples of case studies from England. The aim of this Annex is to help identify the specific context for England in which those decisions are made and the opportunities and barriers to that investment.

This Annex is for anyone who wants to understand the context and key policies and mechanisms for delivery of public realm and walking improvements in England. This includes people new to the sector and people from other sectors or other nations. There are also recommendations for policymakers in England.

This Annex is informed by the findings of a workshop held with stakeholders from the North East in April 2023, hosted by Transport North East and organised by Living Streets. to inform the research for this edition of The Pedestrian Pound. Delegates discussed the impact of walking and active travel measures (e.g., pedestrianisation) introduced since COVID-191 and how to better measure the value of walking. Their roles covered a wide range of expertise: public health, transport (including active travel and transport planning), climate change, economic growth, town centre management, planning, marketing, regeneration and retail consultancy.

Geography and social context

England is the largest nation in the UK, with a population of 57.1 million in 2022 (Office for National Statistics, 2024). The majority (83%) of residents lived in urban areas (17% in rural areas2) in 2020 (Defra and Government Statistical Service, 2024) which means there is plenty of opportunity to improve walking to local, town and city centres.

The UK has larger geographical differences than many other developed countries, with inequalities in productivity, pay, educational attainment and health, both within and between the four nations (Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, 2022). Although average income in England is generally higher than in the other three nations, there are considerable regional differences within England. For example, the North East and Yorkshire and Humber regions have the lowest earnings in the UK, while London and the South East have the highest (Francis-Devine, 2023).

Residents of England generally have poor health and low levels of activity, which, as outlined in the main reportv, could be helped by investment in public realm schemes that encourage more walking. For example:

This is accompanied by large health inequalities, with people living in the most deprived areas of England found to be diagnosed with serious illness earlier and dying sooner than people in more affluent areas (The Health Foundation, 2022).

These regional and health disparities mean that there is a particular need for investment in public realm and walking schemes in the most deprived areas to help residents benefit from the positive impacts on health and wellbeing, economics and community as part of levelling up.

Policy context

High streets and public realm

Policy on public realm improvements in England straddle a number of Government departments but, in the main, comprise the Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities (DLHUC) and the Department for Transport (DfT).

The main policies, strategies and guidance relevant to public realm improvements include:

Many local authorities have public realm improvements as a key part of their regeneration programmes. A wide range of quasi-governmental, private and third sector organisations help to champion placemaking and public realm improvements in England. Key organisations include the High Streets Task Force, an alliance of placemaking experts set up by the UK Government in 2019 to help transform high streets, with a wide range of expertise, training, and data (High Streets Task Force, undated). The Task Force is run by the Institute of Place Management, the professional body for place management (Institute for Place Management, undated). Business Improvement Districts (BIDs)3 also play an important role in supporting placemaking and public realm improvements throughout England (British BIDs, 2018).

Walking

Many public realm improvements involve active travel schemes. The DfT is the main government department responsible for walking policies, strategies and funding, while Active Travel England (ATE) is the executive agency responsible for making walking (and cycling) a preferred choice for travel (Active Travel England, undated).

Unlike the devolved nations, England does not have a central integrated transport strategy, to which all other policies are referenced. Instead, policy is often developed for different modes, sometimes with competing policy goals and trade-offs. For example, the road investment strategy is a five-year multi-billion-pound investment programme in new roads which is expected to increase traffic.

Conversely, a number of policies published in the last five years are focused on prioritising other modes, including walking, such as the Transport Decarbonisation Plan (DfT, 2021a), Gear Change (DfT, 2020), Bus Back Better (DfT, 2021b) and the Williams-Shapps Plan for Rail (DfT, 2021c).

Due to court challenges against its Net Zero Strategy, the UK Government published a new Carbon Budget Delivery Plan (CBDP) in 2023 which included a revised carbon reduction pathway for transport (DfT, 2023a). This, in turn, was the subject of three further legal challenges by climate groups, with the government now legally required to produce a better CBDP by May 2025 (Friends of the Earth, 2024).

Unlike Scotland and Wales, there is no explicit, high-level policy commitment across all government departments to the health and wellbeing of citizens in the UK or England, though the Levelling Up White Paper does include missions on improving health and wellbeing (DLUHC, 2022). Analysis by the British Medical Association in 2019 suggested that ‘physical activity was not being prioritised in the UK’ (British Medical Association, 2019). A long-awaited health disparities White Paper was shelved in 2023 (Nightingale and Merrifield, 2023).

The main policies, strategies and targets relevant to walking include:

Walking levels and mode share

Walking is already important as a mode of travel and currently the only mode of transport in England where average trips per person are above 2018 levels. In 2022, the average person in England (DfT, 2023b):

Walking mode share in England has increased from just over a quarter (27%) in 2018 to nearly a third (31%) of all trips in 2022, though this is partly due to the reduction in total trips (DfT, 2023c).

Academic research has shown that this important and growing role for walking as a mode of travel has multiple benefits for the economy, health and wellbeing, community and the environment (see the main report). Delegates to the workshop argued that this needs to be recognised and well provided for. This is especially the case for shorter trips in the vicinity of residential areas which link people to amenities, education, services and social activities.

Funding context

The governance and funding context in England is very heterogeneous. For example, places such as Greater London with a unique governance structure and powers and Greater Manchester with devolved multi-year funding agreements (similar to the devolved nations), are in a very different situation to councils in smaller (e.g., two-tier) authorities required to competitively bid on a year-by-year basis for smaller pots of funding for public realm and walking improvements.

There are a number of UK Government funds that have recently been or can be used for high streets, public realm and walking improvements in England. These are shown in Table E1.

Through CWIS2, the UK Government has projected spending £3.56 billion on active travel between April 2021 and March 2025 (DfT, 2023d). However, only £1.1 billion of that is dedicated for active travel with the remainder made up of estimates spent on active travel as part of wider government programmes (e.g., Levelling Up) and highways maintenance. It is therefore very difficult to unpick exactly how much has been spent through the various funding programmes, some of which are not exclusively for active travel. Estimates suggest that, over the period 2021-25, the government has cut this dedicated funding by around £430 million (Transport Action Network, 2023).

Table E1: Recent and current funding streams for high streets, public realm and walking improvements in England

Below is a table with each of 10 rows each describing one funding stream. There are five columns, giving (from left to right) the fund name, funding amount, a description, the nation, and a reference.

Name of fund Funding (£) Description Nation Reference
UK Levelling Up Fund (round 3 closed) £4.8 billion Fund for infrastructure including regenerating town centres and high streets, upgrading local transport, and investing in cultural and heritage assets UK DLUHC and Ministry of HCLG, 2021a

Shared Prosperity Fund

(final allocation 2023/24)

£2.6 billion Funding for improvements to town centres and high streets, including better accessibility for disabled people, including capital spend and running costs. All areas of the UK receive an allocation via a funding formula. UK As above
UK Community Ownership Fund (round 4 final round) £150 million Fund to support local facilities, community assets and amenities UK As above
Towns Fund (closed) £3.6 billion Fund to foster regeneration of towns as part of the Levelling Up plan England DLUHC and Ministry of HCLG, 2021b
Future High Streets Fund (closed) 1 billion Fund to renew and reshape town centres and help them reopen and recover from the effects of the pandemic England DLUHC and Ministry of HCLG, 2021c
Brownfield Land Release Fund (closed) £1.5 billion Fund to transform derelict sites in towns and city centres England Local Government Association, undated b
Active Travel Fund £634 million Funding allocations in four tranches (2020-2024) for active travel schemes for local authorities in England England DfT, 2024a
Active Travel Capability Fund £51.5 million Revenue funding for local authorities outside London to develop active travel infrastructure plans and community engagement and training initiatives for the period 2023/24 and 2024/25 England DfT, 2024b
Transforming Cities Fund (closed) £2.45 billion Capital fund to improve productivity by investing in public and sustainable transport infrastructure in English cities (2018-2024) England DfT, 2018b
City Region Sustainable Transport Settlements (closed) £5.7 billion Long-term funding settlements for city regions to develop mass transit networks and sustainable transport options England DfT, 2022a

Delivery and evaluation

The funds listed above have enabled investment in a range of active travel schemes and ATE’s Active Travel Capability Fund is designed to help local authorities outside London to build their capacity to deliver active travel schemes. As well as approving and inspecting schemes to enable active travel, ATE is set up to support local authorities, train staff and spread good practice in design, implementation and public engagement.

However, a report by the National Audit Office (NAO) found that the UK Government is not on track to meet its objectives to increase rates of active travel in England, despite increased ambition in recent years (NAO, 2023). More than half (56%) of local authorities in England were found to have low capability and ambition to deliver active travel projects, which has affected the quality of active travel interventions delivered with government funding to date (ibid.). The establishment of ATE is seen as helpful in tackling some long-standing issues, but the NAO identified a need for longer-term stable funding for active travel, and capacity building to help local authorities deliver schemes (ibid.).

The DfT has also been criticised by another cross-party group of MPs for not doing enough to understand the impact and benefits of active travel funding (House of Commons Public Accounts Committee, 2023). While DfT spent £2.3 billion on active travel schemes between 2016 and 2021, the vast majority of those schemes came under the threshold (of £2 million) where they are required to monitor or evaluate them. The Government agreed with many of the Committee’s recommendations and is now developing a revised approach to evaluation of active travel schemes that have received grant funding, due to be completed in 2026/27 (DfT, 2024c). In the latest round of Active Travel Fund funding, DfT are encouraging schemes above £750,000 to submit a full economic appraisal (ibid.).

At the same time, some analysis has shown that an approach focused predominantly on transport assessments and traffic modelling can get in the way of good placemaking (Create Streets, 2022). There are calls for more vision-led planning and a move away from the ‘predict and provide’ techniques that favour maintenance of the status quo, often road-based solutions, towards an approach based on ‘decide and provide’ (Create Streets and Sustrans, 2024). Among other things, this will require updates to the NPPF to require a ‘vision-led’ approach (ibid.). An independent body advising DfT has also called for a more vision-led approach to planning and recommends reviewing the NPPF to ensure it delivers healthy, low-carbon development with “access to residents’ needs within a short walk or cycle ride” (DfT Science Advisory Council, 2024).

The Government’s levelling up programme has also suffered from delays, with only around a tenth of the funding to tackle regional inequalities spent as of September 2023. It also lacks a mechanism to measure the impacts of the programme (House of Commons Public Accounts Committee, 2024). Further research shows that local councils in England are struggling to invest in levelling up measures due to a lack of ongoing funding, staff and capacity (Taylor et al., 2024).

UK-wide guidance on evaluation for public realm schemes includes:

The most significant England-specific appraisal (and evaluation) tool used for public realm and active travel schemes is Transport Analysis Guidance (TAG).

More information on evaluation can be found in the Evaluation Briefing which accompanies this edition of The Pedestrian Pound.

Workshop findings

Delivery of high street and active travel improvements since COVID-19 were discussed at a workshop in the North East in 2023. While the points raised in that discussion were specific to the North East, they can also be applied to England more generally. For example:

The workshop also discussed how to better measure (and evaluate) the value of walking (e.g., to public health and air quality). Points made by delegates included:

Better data and information: a need for more data about how people use public spaces; details on the origins and destinations of their journeys; how people would like to travel and what the barriers are. It was suggested that public health data and intelligence could be better used, as well as linking the value of walking to public health.

Better evaluation: the value of health indicators and statistics, as well as information about the impact on the NHS, to contribute to the economic case for walking. Delegates also highlighted the importance of quantifying carbon dioxide emissions and looking at the different costs and time of travelling by different modes. It was suggested that Living Streets community street audits of walking routes to check the quality/connectivity of routes should be fed into wayfinding schemes. There was also recognition of the importance of evaluation and a need to ensure there was sufficient funding for it. See the separate Evaluation Briefing for details of how to monitor public realm schemes.

Recommendations

The following recommendations are drawn from both the Newcastle workshop and the reports discussed above:

Policy

Funding

Delivery

Evaluation

Some of the recommendations above, which are common to all three nations, have been included in the main report.

Case studies

See the case studies which accompany this edition of The Pedestrian Pound for examples of public realm improvements in England – and across the UK – which have benefitted pedestrians.

References

Active Travel England (undated) About us. Webpage, undated. https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/active-travel-england/about (accessed 11/07/24).

British Medical Association (2019) Get a move on. Steps to increase physical activity levels in the UK. Report, 2019. https://www.bma.org.uk/media/2104/bma-physical-activity-briefing-get-move-on-oct-19-v2.pdf (accessed 11/07/24).

Bone, Jonathan (2024) A third of adults in Wales live with obesity, according to new analysis. Blog for Nesta, 23/04/24. https://www.nesta.org.uk/blog/a-third-of-adults-in-wales-live-with-obesity-according-to-new-analysis/ (accessed 11/07/24).

British BIDs (2018) Written evidence submitted by British BIDs. House of Commons Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee inquiry into High streets and town centres in 2030. June 2018. https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/92327/html/ (accessed 11/07/24).

CIHT (2010) Manual for Streets 2. Report by the Chartered Institution for Highways and Transportation, September 2010. https://www.ciht.org.uk/media/9351/manual-for-streets-2.pdf (accessed 11/07/24).

Create Streets (2022) Computer Says No. Briefing Paper, February 2022. https://www.createstreets.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/Computer-says-road-1.pdf (accessed 11/07/24).

Create Streets and Sustrans (2024) Stepping off the Road to Nowhere. Report, 10/03/24. https://www.createstreets.com/projects/stepping-off-the-road-to-nowhere/ (accessed 11/07/24).

Defra and Government Statistical Service (2024) Statistical Digest of Rural England:1 – Population. April 2024. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/661d3b95ac3dae9a53bd3dd3/16_04_2024_-_1_-_Population.pdf (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities (2021) National Planning Policy Framework. Revised 20/12/23. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-planning-policy-framework--2 (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities (2022) Levelling up the United Kingdom. White Paper. February 2022. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/levelling-up-the-united-kingdom (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities and Ministry for Housing, Communities & Local Government (2020) Flexible use on the high street: key facts brief. Guidance, 18/09/20. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/permitted-development-rights-and-changes-to-the-use-classes-order/flexible-use-on-the-high-street-key-facts-brief (accessed 09/07/24).

Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities and Ministry of Housing, Communities & Local Government (2021a) New Levelling Up and community investments. https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/new-levelling-up-and-community-investments (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities and Ministry of Housing, Communities & Local Government (2021b) Towns Fund Webpage. https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/towns-fund (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities and Ministry of Housing, Communities & Local Government (2021c) Future High Streets Fund. Webpage, updated 02/12/21.https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/future-high-streets-fund (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities (2024) UKSPF Evaluation Strategy. Guidance 04/03/24. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/uk-shared-prosperity-fund-evaluation/ukspf-evaluation-strategy (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2007) Manual for Streets. Report, 29/03/07. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/manual-for-streets (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2017a) Cycling Walking Investment Strategy. Policy paper, 21/04/17. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/cycling-and-walking-investment-strategy (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2017b) Local Cycling and Walking Infrastructure Plans. Technical Guidance for Local Authorities. April 2017. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5f32aa668fa8f57ac88dc9dc/cycling-walking-infrastructure-technical-guidance-document.pdf (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2018a) The second cycling and walking investment strategy. Policy paper, 10/03/18. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-second-cycling-and-walking-investment-strategy/the-second-cycling-and-walking-investment-strategy-cwis2 (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2018b) Transforming Cities Fund. Webpage/ https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/apply-for-the-transforming-cities-fund (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2020) Gear Change: a bold vision for cycling and walking. July 2020. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5f1f59458fa8f53d39c0def9/gear-change-a-bold-vision-for-cycling-and-walking.pdf (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2021a) Decarbonising transport: a better, greener Britain. Guidance, July 2021. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/transport-decarbonisation-plan (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2021b) Bus Back Better. Policy paper, 15/03/21. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/bus-back-better (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2021c) Great British Railways: Williams Shapps Plan. Policy paper, 20/05/21. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/great-british-railways-williams-shapps-plan-for-rail (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2021d) Gear Change: one year on review. July 2021 https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/gear-change-one-year-on-review (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2022a) City Region Sustainable Transport Settlements: confirmed delivery plans and funding allocations. 29/07/22. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/city-region-sustainable-transport-settlements-confirmed-delivery-plans-and-funding-allocations (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2022b) Cycling and Walking Investment Strategy Report to Parliament 2022. July 2022. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/62c311cfe90e077487746ee3/Cycling-and-walking-investment-strategy-report-to-Parliament-2022-web.pdf (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2023a) Carbon Budget Delivery Plan. Policy paper, March 2023. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/carbon-budget-delivery-plan (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2023b) Walking and Cycling Statistics, England. August 2023. https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/walking-and-cycling-statistics-england-2022/walking-and-cycling-statistics-england-introduction-and-main-findings (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2023c) National Travel Survey. Table NTS0308a: Average number of trips by trip length and main ps per person per year): England, 2002 onwards. https://www.gov.uk/government/statistical-data-sets/nts03-modal-comparisons#trips-stages-distance-and-time-spent-travelling (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2023d) The second cycling and walking investment strategy (CWIS2). Updated 10/03/23. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-second-cycling-and-walking-investment-strategy/the-second-cycling-and-walking-investment-strategy-cwis2 (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2024a) Active Travel Fund: local transport authority allocations . Update 23/03/24. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/emergency-active-travel-fund-local-transport-authority-allocations (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2024b) Active travel capability fund: local transport authority allocations. Update 23/03/24. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/capability-fund-local-transport-authority-allocations (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2024c) Government response to the Committee of Public Accounts on the Seventy-fifth report from Session 2022-23. 14/02/24. https://committees.parliament.uk/work/7729/active-travel-in-england/publications/ (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport (2024d) Transport Analysis Guidance. Updated 25/04/24. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/transport-analysis-guidance-tag (accessed 11/07/24).

Department for Transport Science Advisory Council (2024) Land use and transport planning. Paper, 29/04/24. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/land-use-and-transport-planning-dft-science-advisory-council-paper/land-use-and-transport-planning-dft-science-advisory-council-paper (accessed 11/07/24).

Francis-Devine B (2023) h Average earnings by age and region. House of Commons Research Briefing, 18/12/23. https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-8456/ (accessed 11/07/24).

Friends of the Earth (2024) Landmark High Court judgment finds government’s climate plan ‘unlawful’ – again. Press release, 02/05/24. https://friendsoftheearth.uk/latest/landmark-high-court-judgment-finds-governments-climate-plan-unlawful-again (accessed 11/07/24).

High Streets Task Force (undated). Webpage https://www.highstreetstaskforce.org.uk/ (accessed 11/07/24).

House of Commons Public Accounts Committee (2023) Active travel in England. Seventy-Fifth Report of Session 2022–23. 16/10/23. https://committees.parliament.uk/publications/41918/documents/209082/default/ (accessed 11/07/24).

House of Commons Public Accounts Committee (2024) Levelling up funding to local government. Twenty-first report of session 2023-24. 15/03/24. https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm5804/cmselect/cmpubacc/424/report.html (accessed 16/07/24).

Institute of Place Management (undated) Website, undated. https://www.placemanagement.org/ (accessed 11/07/24).

Local Government Association (undated a) Revitalising town centres: a toolkit for councils. https://www.local.gov.uk/topics/economic-growth/revitalising-town-centres-toolkit-councils (accessed 11/07/24).

Local Government Association (undated b) Brownfield Land Release Fund. Webpage. https://www.local.gov.uk/topics/housing-and-planning/one-public-estate/brownfield-land-release-fund (accessed 11/07/24).

Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (2021) Build Back Better High Streets. Policy paper, July 2021. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1005041/Build_Back_Better_High_Streets.pdf (accessed 11/07/24).

National Audit Office (NAO) (2023) Active Travel in England. Report – value for money. Report, 07/06/23. https://www.nao.org.uk/reports/active-travel-in-england/ (accessed 11/07/24).

Nightingale G and Merrifield K (2023) The health disparities white paper disappearing shows a dangerous pattern for action on health. Blog for The Health Foundation, 27/01/23. https://www.health.org.uk/news-and-comment/blogs/the-health-disparities-white-paper-disappearing-shows-a-dangerous-pattern (accessed 11/07/24).

Office for National Statistics (2024) Population estimates for the UK, England, Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland: mid-2022. Release, 26/03/24. https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populationandmigration/populationestimates/bulletins/annualmidyearpopulationestimates/latest (accessed 11/07/24).

Rankl, Felicia (2024) Debate on reform of the planning system. House of Commons Library Research Briefing, 12/03/24. https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cdp-2024-0052/ (accessed 11/07/24).

The Health Foundation (2022) Major study outlines wide health inequalities in England. News release, 15/08/22. https://www.health.org.uk/news-and-comment/news/major-study-outlines-wide-health-inequalities-in-england (accessed 11/07/24).

Taylor A, Green A and Read H (2024) Levelling up is not working as promised – our research shows why. Article in The Conversation, 15/03/24. https://theconversation.com/levelling-up-is-not-working-as-promised-our-research-shows-why-224285 (accessed 11/07/24).

Transport Action Network (2023) Statement of Facts and Grounds. CWIS2 challenge legal case, 06/06/23. https://transportactionnetwork.org.uk/cwis2-legal-papers/ (accessed 11/07/24).